Bookkeeper vs. Accountant vs. Controller: Who Does What for Your Small Business?

Northstar Flag Favicon with star and three stripes

Small businesses often face the challenge of managing their finances effectively. As your business grows, you might wonder who to hire to handle your financial tasks. There are bookkeepers, accountants, and controllers, and it can be confusing to understand the differences between them. Knowing what each professional does can help you make the right decision for your business. NorthStar Bookkeeping serves small to mid-size businesses, including law firms, property management firms, and construction firms, in Orange County, CA, and across the United States. This article will explain the roles of bookkeepers, accountants, and controllers, helping you determine who your business needs.

Bookkeeper

A bookkeeper is responsible for the day-to-day financial record-keeping of your business. They ensure that all transactions are accurately recorded and organized.

Key responsibilities of a bookkeeper include:

  • Recording financial transactions: This involves entering data from invoices, receipts, and bank statements into the accounting system.
  • Managing accounts payable and receivable: Bookkeepers track what your business owes to others and what others owe to your business.
  • Reconciling bank statements: This process ensures that the bank’s records match your business’s records.
  • Preparing financial reports: Bookkeepers generate basic financial statements like income statements and balance sheets
  • Handling payroll: Some bookkeepers manage the payroll process, including calculating wages and processing payments.

“Bookkeeping is the foundation of any business’s financial health,” says Paul Yee, co-owner of NorthStar Bookkeeping. “Accurate and timely record-keeping ensures that you have a clear picture of your finances, which is essential for making informed business decisions.”

A bookkeeper’s work is crucial for maintaining organized and up-to-date financial records. For instance, in property management, a bookkeeper ensures that all income and expenses are correctly categorized in the chart of accounts, providing clarity on the property’s financial performance.

Accountant

An accountant analyzes and interprets the financial information recorded by the bookkeeper. While bookkeepers focus on recording transactions, accountants provide insights and advice to help you make strategic business decisions.

Key responsibilities of an accountant include:

  • Preparing financial statements: Accountants create detailed financial reports that provide a comprehensive view of your business’s financial health.
  • Analyzing financial data: They examine financial statements to identify trends, opportunities, and potential risks.
  • Providing financial advice: Accountants offer guidance on budgeting, financial planning, and cost management.
  • Tax planning and preparation: Accountants help businesses comply with tax laws and optimize their tax strategy.
  • Auditing: Some accountants conduct internal or external audits to ensure the accuracy of financial records.

Accountants play a vital role in ensuring financial compliance and providing strategic financial direction. In construction accounting, for example, accountants ensure that financial practices adhere to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), which is essential for financial integrity and transparency.

“Accountants bring a higher level of financial expertise to the table,” says Heather Kirstein, co-owner of NorthStar Bookkeeping. “They not only ensure that your financial records are accurate but also provide valuable insights that can drive your business forward.”

Controller

A controller is a senior-level accounting professional who oversees the accounting operations of a company. In larger organizations, the controller manages the accounting staff and ensures that financial activities are aligned with the company’s goals.

Key responsibilities of a controller include:

  • Managing accounting staff: Controllers supervise bookkeepers and accountants, ensuring that the accounting department runs smoothly.
  • Developing financial policies and procedures: They establish and implement internal controls to safeguard assets and ensure accurate financial reporting.
  • Preparing financial reports for management: Controllers provide high-level financial analysis and reports to help management make strategic decisions.
  • Budgeting and forecasting: They oversee the budgeting process and develop financial forecasts to guide future planning.
  • Ensuring compliance: Controllers ensure that the company complies with financial regulations and accounting standards.

Controllers are essential for larger companies that require sophisticated financial management and strategic planning. They provide the financial leadership necessary to support the company’s growth and stability.

Yee notes, “A controller acts as the financial backbone of an organization, providing the oversight and strategic direction needed to achieve long-term financial health.”

Key Differences: Bookkeeper vs. Accountant vs. Controller

To summarize, here are the key differences between bookkeepers, accountants, and controllers:

  • Focus: Bookkeepers focus on recording daily transactions, accountants analyze financial data and provide advice, and controllers oversee the entire accounting function.
  • Expertise: Bookkeepers have basic accounting knowledge, accountants have a deeper understanding of accounting principles, and controllers possess advanced financial management skills.
  • Responsibilities: Bookkeepers handle record-keeping, accountants provide analysis and advice, and controllers manage accounting staff and develop financial strategies.
  • Level: Bookkeepers are entry-level professionals, accountants are mid-level, and controllers are senior-level.

This table illustrates the differences:

RoleFocusExpertiseResponsibilities
BookkeeperRecording transactionsBasic accounting knowledgeRecord daily transactions, manage accounts payable/receivable, reconcile bank statements, prepare basic financial reports, handle payroll.
AccountantAnalyzing financial dataDeeper understanding of accounting principlesPrepare financial statements, analyze financial data, provide financial advice, tax planning and preparation, auditing.
ControllerOverseeing accounting functionAdvanced financial management skillsManage accounting staff, develop financial policies and procedures, prepare financial reports for management, budgeting and forecasting, ensure compliance.

Which Professional Does Your Business Need?

The right financial professional for your business depends on its size, complexity, and specific needs.  Small businesses with straightforward finances may only need a bookkeeper to handle daily transactions and basic reporting. Growing businesses or those with more complex finances may benefit from hiring an accountant to provide analysis, advice, and tax planning. Larger companies with significant financial operations often require a controller to oversee the accounting department and develop financial strategies.

“Many small businesses start with a bookkeeper and then add an accountant as their needs become more complex,” says Kirstein. “It’s about scaling your financial support with your business growth.”

For example, law firms and construction companies often have unique accounting needs. Law firms require careful handling of client trust accounts and compliance with specific regulations. Construction companies need to manage project costs, revenue recognition, and GAAP compliance. In these cases, both accountants and bookkeepers with specialized knowledge are essential. NorthStar Bookkeeping serves these types of niche companies. If you’re unsure which professional your business needs, call us at (714) 608-1526 for a consultation.

Outsourcing Your Bookkeeping and Accounting

NorthStar Bookkeeping offers outsourced bookkeeping services to businesses of all sizes. By entrusting your bookkeeping and back-end administration to a responsive and responsible partner, you’ll free up your working hours for the tasks that only you can do. And it’s safe to say that your accounts will be more up-to-date and accurate with NorthStar’s team of experts overseeing them than they were when you were trying to do everything yourself. 

Understanding the differences between bookkeepers, accountants, and controllers is essential for making informed decisions about your business’s financial management. Whether you need help with daily record-keeping, financial analysis, or strategic planning, there’s a financial professional who can meet your needs. NorthStar Bookkeeping serves businesses in Orange County, CA, and across the United States, offering outsourced bookkeeping and accounting solutions tailored to your specific requirements. Contact us today at (714) 608-1526 to discuss your bookkeeping needs.

Move Your Organization Forward With Northstar

Start your journey with NorthStar by scheduling a conversation.

We’ll map out our next steps together